Black eye? Ouch. Red eye? Exhausting. Pink eye? Never, ever good. Then there’s ol’ blue eyes (and we’re not talking about Frank Sinatra!). Benefit BADgal Blue Mascara applies to lashes in deep violet instead of the usual, clumpy black. The blue hue helps to visually open up the lid and enhance eye color, making even the darkest of brown eyes sparkle. So going from the same, boring black mascara to rebellious blue? How BADgirl of you! (And PS, you didn’t even have to give anyone a black eye.)

Value: $19